![]()
ADVISORY NEIGHBORHOOD
COMMISSION 1B
Government of the
MINUTES
2 February 2006,
Attending: Commissioners Moss, Spalding, Hunter, M. Smith, Stephens, Z. Wright, Akinmboni,
T. Smith, Mathews
Absent: Commissioners Hammonds, R. Wright
Quorum was achieved at 7PM.
Commissioner Spalding moved that ANC1B appoint Zachary Wright to fill
the vacancy in 1B07 as the only name forwarded by the DC Board of Elections and
Ethics, and it was seconded and adopted unanimously (7-0). In the Treasurer’s Report Commissioner
Stephens presented the 1st Quarter 2006 Report indicating an initial
balance of $72,814.00, a deposit of $7739.55, disbursements of $4542.08, and an
ending balance of $76.011.47. First
Quarter Report was moved, seconded and adopted (9-0). Treasurer Stephens presented the proposed
budget for 2006. Included in line item
disbursements is $7,500 for postage, $2,000 for printing, $6,000 for purchase
of service, $2,400 for office supplies, $10,000 for grants, $6,000 for
training, and $180.00 for bank charges, totaling $34,080. Treasurer Stephens stated that we are not
bound to these figures, but are required to submit a budget to the Auditor for
the upcoming year. ANC1B proposed budget
was moved and seconded. Commissioner
Mathews questioned the allotment for training, and Chairman Hunter explained
that the Commission is planning on presenting issue forums and that this line
item would be to support the expenses of the forums. Budget was adopted (8-0-1) with Commissioner
Mathews abstaining. Treasurer stated
that he does not have a monthly report and will present it at the March
meeting, and moved reimbursing secretarial expenses for January for $108.27,
and it was seconded and adopted (9-0).
In the Secretary’s report Commissioner Spalding stated that at the
informal meeting it was decided to begin the process of requesting office
space, and that this entails requesting the space from the Mayor and the Office
of Property Management. Secretary moved
that ANC1B request office space from the Mayor, and it was seconded and adopted
(9-0). Secretary stated that he has
spoken with the Public Welfare Foundation in regard to room reservations for
the proposed forums, and Chairman Hunter asked that we wait for discussion and
approval of the forums prior to discussion of the room reservations. Secretary moved adoption of the January 2006
minutes, and it was seconded and adopted (9-0).
Chairman Hunter introduced consideration of three public forums to be
held by the Commission dealing with transportation, economic development, and
public benefits packages.
Chairman Hunter introduced reconsideration of Zoning
Commission case 05-17, Broadway Atlantic One LLC’s planned unit development
application. Commissioner Hunter
explained that the Commission voted not to support the application last month
based on concerns over the public benefits package. Commissioners Hunter, Moss and Spalding met
with the developer to discuss these issues, and I am pleased to announce that
we’ve reached an agreement that will allow the ANC to approve the PUD at this
time. Chairman Hunter stated that the
affordable housing component had been questioned at our previous meeting,
however, in meeting with the developer and comparing to other private
development PUD affordable housing components we recognized that 15% of the
bonus is the highest amongst the private developments. I am also pleased to announce that Broadway
has agreed to allocate an additional $100,000 in community benefits to be
distributed by the ANC to various community organizations and projects. This is a significant contribution and makes
this the largest community benefit package for a private PUD in the
District. The BZA has allowed the record
to stay open until February 13th for our comments. It’s my hope that we’ll approve this tonight
and then prior to February 13th meet and come up with some tentative
recommendations on the allocation of this $100,000. Then it would be my hope that we’d come back
at our March meeting and formally vote on the allocation of that $100,000. This is truly an historic
accomplishment. Commissioner T. Smith
questioned the scale of the project that was also discussed at our January
meeting, and Chairman Hunter explained that the added density and retail
arguably are going to help improve the property values of other people in that
particular area. Commissioner T. Smith
responded by asking whether the influence of this project on forcing long term
residents out of the neighborhood had been assessed, and Chairman Hunter
responded that this is building on vacant lots and the increased value would
also accrue to current property holders in the area. Commissioner Akinmboni stated that the rise
in property values was affecting the ability of current owners to maintain
control of their properties due to the increase in taxation. Chairman Hunter responded that in further
exploration of the design a number of the units being sold at market rate are
close to affordable housing in today’s market.
Commissioner Mathews asked for clarification on what changes had
occurred, and that the fifteen percent of bonus density appears to be the same
as offered at the January meeting, and that the Commission would be getting an
additional $100,000. Chairman Hunter
responded that several things have changed.
My understanding of the projects details has changed. Now that we know that fifteen percent of
bonus density rises to the level of a record for private developers in the
city, that’s an important thing for us.
We have also had an offer of $100,000 influx into our community for
programs and community organizations.
Commissioner Mathews argued that there’s an affordable housing crisis in
the city, and to have the Commission’s mind changed just because they gave
$100,000 seems to me to be a little bit suspect. Chairman Hunter responded that this is a
private development, and in the cases of city involvement e.g. NCRC we can get
a higher number of affordable units.
Arguably, if we can continue to get a fifteen per cent affordable
component out of private developers, then this may be larger than the proposed
inclusionary zoning arrangement being considered by the city. Commissioner Stephens stated that he would
again vote to support the application, but we need to get out of the business
of nickel and diming each developer who comes before us. We need further discussion that will
hopefully take place in the forums, on how to put responsibility for affordable
housing on other people than those who are coming in and building on empty lots
in this city. Commissioner Moss thanked
Broadway for their ongoing engagement with community members and
organizations. A discussion of what
‘affordable housing’ currently means was discussed. Norm Veenstra asked for further description
of the retail component, and Allison Prince representing Broadway stated that
they have not decided on whether the retail would be sold or retained. Mr. Veenstra asked about the developer’s
commitment to local business operators who may want consideration for retail
space. Chairman Hunter responded that
this portion of the PUD has already been decided, but that the developer has
shown good will in negotiations surrounding the retail components of the
project.
Commissioner Spalding introduced consideration of BZA 17466
of
Commissioner M. Smith introduced consideration of BZA 17436
for special exception from 2116.2 for property located at
Commissioner Moss introduced consideration of HPRB 06-023
for a two story rear addition at
Commissioner Moss introduced HPRB 06-071 and noted that HPRB
denied the architect’s design for additions to
Commissioner Spalding introduced HPRB 06-041 regarding a
third floor addition to
Commissioner Moss introduced consideration of HPRB case for
an addition to
Commissioner Moss introduced Mayor’s Agent case HPA 06-062
located at
Commissioner Stephens reported on negotiations with
developer of
Commissioner T. Smith introduced consideration of a request
from residents of the 700 block of
Commissioner Spalding introduced an ABRA application for a
new CT license to be located in the 1800 block of
Commissioner Spalding moved to table consideration, and it was seconded and adopted (9-0).
Chairman Hunter moved that no application for an ABRA license be placed on the agenda until the application has been filed and the establishment has been placarded, and it was seconded. Commissioner Stephens cautioned that we consider our August recess and not tie our hands in voting consideration due to scheduling. Commissioner Spalding asked that this be further researched in consideration of Commissioner Stephens’ concern over scheduling. Our ability to comment on licenses works within a tight notification window, and we should be cautious about limiting the Commission’s ability to review and vote on applications when possibly losing our ability to comment. Chairman Hunter offered that we could change the rule to state that we would automatically reject all applications until their placarding is in place. Motion was adopted (8-0-1) with Commissioner Mathews abstaining.
Commissioner Moss introduced reconsideration of Cookie’s Corner. This was before us in December and we voted it down. This now has a new owner known to the local community. I move that ANC1B now support this application since the new owner has a track record of running a business and a solid liquor license. Motion was seconded. Commissioner Spalding asked if we have a business plan for the new business, and Commissioner Moss responded that she has met with the owner of the LeDroit Park Market. Commissioner Spalding asked if this is going to be a Class B store, and Commissioner Moss responded that it’s going to be a combination of café, sandwich shop and Class B store. Commissioner Spalding asked why the Commission has not received notification from ABRA if the application has been filed and the placards are up, and Chairman Hunter responded that we should check with ABRA. Commissioner Spalding asked if the license is in safekeeping, and Commissioner Moss responded that it is. Commissioner Spalding stated that what we have is a transfer of a license that is currently in safekeeping. Commissioner Stephens asked how many years does the approved license run, and Commissioner Spalding responded that it would be for three years prior to renewal. Motion was adopted (9-0).
Chairman Hunter asked to take presentations prior to grants,
and there was no objection. Commissioner
Spalding introduced consideration of support for PR 16-584 the Neighborhood
Investment Act FY2006, and specifically monies to support the ‘Green Team’
included in the bill. Scott Pomeroy gave
the history of the Green Team.
Established by the 14th and U Main Streets program, it was
operating for fifteen months with funding from UDC and PN Hoffman. The legislation was proposed in 2003 and is
just now being heard, and the monies would support continuance of the
program. This program works with the
homeless and trains them to work as street cleaning and ambassadorial
personnel. This is a program that helps
provide cleaner safer streets similar to the downtown bids. Mr. Pomeroy handed out further details on the
participating agencies, the DC government agencies benefiting from existence of
the Green Team, and details on the funding.
The included $350,000 requested for the Green Team is a small portion of
the large bills consideration of numerous city wide neighborhood projects, and
we’re looking for support for this local portion of the bill. Motion was made to support, and it was
seconded. Chairman Hunter asked how many
people would be employed, and Mr. Pomeroy replied that it would be ten full
time employees during the weekdays, and ten part time on weekends. Chairman Hunter asked for the boundaries, and
Mr. Pomeroy responded that it would be
Commissioner Moss introduced Cindy K. Keim of Vitas Innovative Hospice Care. Ms. Keim stated that they are the leading hospice care company in the country, and they are applying for providing hospice care in the District. Their research shows that there are 389 people per day in need of hospice care, and Vitas wants to provide that care. A general review of hospice care was provided. Chairman Hunter asked about their current employment, and Ms. Keim responded that she’s alone right now, but that with the issuance of the license they expect to have about fifty employees by the end of this year.
Commissioner Stephens introduced review of WMATA Yellow line
extension. I would like to thank Scott
Pomeroy for bringing together a great forum and getting WMATA involved in
active consideration of this proposal.
Commissioner Stephens moved that: ANC1B urges WMATA to move forward on
proposals to extend Metro service in the
Commissioner Stephens stated that he is not the grant coordinator. If you want to be considered for a grant, then the paperwork must go to the Secretary. I did receive in a timely fashion a grant application, but I was not aware that it had not been circulated nor on the agenda. I am in support of this application. Secretary Spalding asked for clarification about his duties, and Chairman Hunter responded that if received fourteen days prior to the next scheduled regular meeting, a grant application should be placed on the agenda and circulated to Commissioners. Alexandria Price, project coordinator at Garfield Terrace, asked for $2,000 for supplies for the computer center at Garfield Terrace. This should have a positive influence on fifty children living in the community. Chairman Hunter asked where the equipment would be housed, and Ms. Price responded that there is a room already in place in the community center for this purpose. Treasurer Stephens asked what organizations were participating in the grant application, and the Garfield Family Council and the Garfield Terrace Tenants Association were named. Treasurer Stephens cautioned that any equipment purchased had to remain the property of the Commission, so the grant should be asking for other portions of the larger budget. Commissioner Akinmboni moved support of the grant, and it was seconded, and adopted (7-1-1) with Commissioner Spalding opposing.
Treasurer Stephens reviewed compliance and reporting from previously issued grants as requested at our January meeting. Letters were sent to grantees with reporting problems, and none of them are here to answer to the Commission this evening. They are: $4,000 to History of Rhythm and Blues, Jazz and Gospel Black and White Inc, awarded on August 5, 2004, with Dr. Sandra Butler Truesdale the responsible party; $4,000 to the Arts for Youth and Senior Citizens Generational program, awarded on August 5, 2004, with Dr. Sandra Butler Truesdale the responsible party; $1,000 to the Faircliff Tenants West, on September 1st 2005, with Shiela Abney Minor the responsible party; $2,000 to the Blackout Arts Collaborative, in September of 2004, and there is $250 outstanding and we haven’t heard from them in six months. Chairman Hunter asked for details on the Grant to Tony Norman, and Treasurer Stephens responded that Mr. Norman is not named in the grant but has been the communicant with the Commission on the grant and reporting. The Auditor stated that they have satisfied their requirements, but to my own understanding there are outstanding issues to be resolved. Chairman Hunter stated that we want to keep track of who is not complying with our documentation rules, and I want the last of these to be presented at our next meeting.
The last issue that we have is when we are going to meet and discuss the $100,000 and how we are going to deal with this. We have until February 13th to generate a preliminary list of recipients. We should start this with some emails. Commissioner Akinmboni asked if there were any restrictions on how we work with these funds, and Chairman Hunter responded technically no. Numerous days and hours were suggested. Commissioner Stephens requested that the Commission receive no funds as a part of the agreement. Chairman Hunter stated that all of this can be worked out when we meet, so let’s find a time to meet. More discussion of meeting times and problems with them ensued. Chairman Hunter borrowed the Secretary’s scheduling book and suggested Wednesday, February 8th in the evening. Chairman Hunter asked what the meeting scheduled in Commissioner Spalding’s book was, and Commissioner Spalding responded that it was meetings with parties involved in two liquor license application protests. Chairman Hunter stated that it’s going to take some time for us to flesh out some ideas. I think it’s important that some of the funds go to the affected area, but here’s an opportunity for us to disperse monies to parts of our area that don’t normally get it. Commissioner Moss suggested that each Commissioner put forth three or four recommendations, and that we can review these at the meeting. More discussion of scheduling problems followed. Chairman Hunter set the meeting for Wednesday, February 8th. Chairman Hunter told Commissioner Spalding to move his scheduled meeting on the liquor protests, and Commissioner Spalding stated that he could not move the meeting but his presence was not required at the benefits meeting. Chairman Hunter set the meeting for Wednesday, February 8th at 7PM at a location to be determined.
Commission adjourned at 9:40PM.